Common Payroll Mistakes Made by Small Businesses
Payroll can seem pretty straightforward until something goes wrong. Between paying employees, withholding the right taxes, meeting deadlines, and keeping up with changing requirements, there are a lot of details to manage.
For small business owners who are already juggling day-to-day operations, payroll mistakes can lead to penalties, frustrated employees, and extra work. The good news is that many common mistakes are preventable. Here are a few things to watch out for.
Misclassifying Employees and Independent Contractors
One common mistake is incorrectly classifying workers as independent contractors instead of employees. The classification depends on the nature of the working relationship, not simply how the business chooses to pay someone.
Employees generally require payroll tax withholding and employer payroll taxes, while independent contractors are typically responsible for their own self-employment taxes. Misclassification can result in back taxes, penalties, and other complications. If you're unsure how someone should be classified, it's best to address the question before payments begin.
Getting Payroll Taxes Right
Payroll involves more than calculating an employee's take-home pay. Employers must account for applicable income tax withholding, Social Security and Medicare taxes, and unemployment taxes.
Errors can happen when employee information is entered incorrectly, withholding elections aren't updated, or tax calculations aren't correct. It's important to keep employee information and withholding elections up to date, make sure payroll is set up properly, and check payroll reports periodically for unusual amounts or discrepancies.

Missing Payroll Tax Deadlines
Employers have federal, state, and sometimes local payroll tax filing and payment requirements. Missing a deadline can result in penalties and interest.
It's also important to remember that filing a tax return and making the associated payment are separate responsibilities. Payroll software may automate both, but business owners should confirm which services are enabled and check for any errors or alerts rather than assuming everything has been handled.
It's also important to open and respond to notices from the IRS or state and local tax agencies. These notices may relate to missed payments, filing discrepancies, or other payroll tax issues. Addressing them promptly can help prevent additional penalties, interest, or other complications.
Running All Employee Payments Through Payroll
It's important to make sure all payments to employees are processed through payroll, not just regular wages or salaries. Bonuses, commissions, and other forms of compensation may also need to be included in payroll and are generally subject to applicable tax withholding and reporting requirements.
Sometimes, business owners pay a bonus separately or give an employee extra money outside of their normal paycheck without realizing it still needs to be reported through payroll. This can lead to incorrect tax withholding, inaccurate payroll records, and additional work to correct the issue later.
When in doubt, check with your payroll provider or accountant before making payments to employees outside of the normal payroll process.
Failing to Reconcile Payroll to Your Books
Payroll doesn't end when employees receive their paychecks. Payroll expenses, tax withholdings, employer taxes, and payments to tax agencies need to be recorded correctly in your accounting system.
If payroll entries don't match payroll reports or tax payments aren't recorded properly, your financial statements may be inaccurate. Periodically reconciling payroll to your accounting records and checking outstanding payroll tax liabilities can help catch problems before year-end.
Assuming Payroll Software Handles Everything
Payroll software can save time, but it doesn't eliminate the need for oversight. Automated filings and payments may require proper setup and authorization, and errors or rejected payments can still occur.
Make sure you understand what your payroll provider handles and what remains your responsibility. Checking payroll reports and addressing alerts or errors regularly can help prevent small issues from becoming bigger problems.
Make Payroll a Routine, Not a Last-Minute Task
Payroll mistakes can happen to any business, but consistent procedures can reduce the risk. Keep employee information current, monitor deadlines, track hours accurately, and periodically check that payroll reports agree with your accounting records.
At FPG Tax & Accounting, we help small businesses stay on top of their payroll-related accounting and tax responsibilities. Even when payroll is handled through an outside provider, it's important to make sure payroll taxes are paid and filed correctly and that payroll activity is accurately reflected in your books.
Have questions about your business's payroll-related responsibilities? Contact FPG Tax & Accounting at jessica@fpgtax.com or call us at (816) 941-2900.






Comments